Aerosmith frontman and ‘American Idol‘ judge Steven Tyler is catching a ton of flack for his less than stellar version of ‘The Star-Spangled Banner,’ which he sang before the AFC championship game between the New England Patriots and the Baltimore Ravens.

But was Tony award winning Broadway actress Kristin Chenoweth’s any better? Kristin, who sang the National Anthem before the NFC championship game between the 49’ers and the Giants, sung her renditon in the style of Kate Smith’s “God Bless America”. She’s getting most of the love on the internet this morning, but was it really that good, or did you find it to be a bit over the top? We Report, You Decide. Watch the videos below, then cast your vote.

Steven Tyler Star Mangled Banner ...

Kristin Chenowerth Star Manlged Banner ...